Almost Perfect by Brian Katcher


almost perfectWhat if everything you believed to be true about someone was a lie? Well, not EVERYTHING. Just one thing. But it’s the one thing that changes everything. High school senior and small town boy Logan Witherspoon has the rug pulled out from under him when smart, sexy, funny new girl Sage reveals after their first kiss that she is biologically a boy. Hurt, confused and angry, Logan at first wants nothing more to do with her. But he misses Sage’s laughter and easy banter more than he thought, and soon he can no longer deny his physical feelings for her. The thing is, Sage LOOKS like a girl, ACTS like a girl, SMELLS like a girl and for all intensive purposes IS a girl in every way except, well, THAT one. Logan has never met a transgendered person in his life and has no idea how to navigate this new relationship. Does his attraction to Sage mean that he’s gay? What if someone finds out about Sage? Is he prepared to stand up for her? How can he explain Sage to his family and friends, and does he even have to? All because of “one teeny, little, microscopic, enormous, universe-sized complication,” Logan’s world has been turned upside down, and instead of answers he just keeps finding more questions. The biggest question of all is if he knows how to be a true friend to someone when she needs him the most. Unfortunately, that’s the one question Logan is having the most trouble answering. This honest, funny, and often heartbreaking book openly addresses the prejudices and misconceptions often held about transgendered people and puts them out there for us to examine, understand and hopefully discard as nonsense and ignorance. What Logan painfully comes to understand is that you fall in love with a person, not a gender, and that if you let it, love will always find a way. Make sure to check out Katcher’s equally excellent first novel, Playing with Matches.)

7 Responses to “Almost Perfect by Brian Katcher”

  1. Abby says:

    This one looks awesome. Thanks for posting about it!

  2. Karissa F. says:

    i think this looks like a REALLY interesting book. guys should read it too. hint hint. 🙂

  3. C says:

    amazing! i’ll totally read haha!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  4. Tiara says:

    I have this book and it is awesome i love it i would reccomend you all read it.

  5. Marga says:

    This book looks really funny. Haha

  6. Sarah says:

    I have not read this book yet, but I have to say that it seems problematic to me given that Sage’s trans-ness is portrayed as deception. Someone who’s trans isn’t lying about their gender. If they are a MTF trans person than they ARE a woman, if they are a FTM trans person then they ARE a man. Is this addressed in the book?

  7. Brittany says:

    I loved it 🙂

Your Reply


Jen Hubert Swan
Librarian, Book Reviewer,
Reading Addict